Going Deeper
Organizations interested in business strategies to support population health should consider embracing opportunities to adopt capitated payment, where practices are paid a fixed, per-patient monthly amount to cover all primary care services. This type of fixed payment enables practices to make investments in care team roles and modes of patient interaction that may not be billable in a traditional fee-for-service environment, generating new opportunities for patient engagement and improvement in outcomes.[1][2] Capitated payment alone, however, will not drive improvements in population health.
In order for payment reform to have the greatest effect on population health, payment must be designed to drive behavior change for the health system, administrators, providers and care teams. The Health Care Payment Learning and Action Network offers a widely used framework for classifying alternative payment models for healthcare.[3] This framework describes a continuum of options for healthcare payment, from the traditional fee-for-service approach to alternative payment models linked to quality through upside-only or upside and downside risk, all the way to payment built entirely on population parameters.
FIGURE 1: HEALTH CARE PAYMENT LEARNING & ACTION NETWORK (HCP LAN) UPDATED ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT MODEL FRAMEWORK

Studies of value-based payment implementation over the past decade suggest that small shifts away from fee-for-service payment produce only small effects, and that both intentional model design and focused accountability are critical for leveraging payment reform to improve patient experience, outcomes and equity.[4] Although there is a significant opportunity to create mutual leverage between alternative payment and care model transformation, succeeding with this strategy requires clinical vision, effective leadership with appropriate financial, clinical and administrative capabilities, and organizational resources to build the operational competencies to rethink how primary care is delivered.[5][6]
Despite the substantial care improvement opportunities enabled by capitation, there is an increasingly complex and uneven payment reform landscape for healthcare organizations considering participation. Opportunities for and participation in payment reform tend to be uneven at both the state and health center levels, with more capitation and value-based payment activity present in some states than others, and lower participation in value-based payment arrangements among smaller health centers.[7] Participation in clinically integrated networks or independent provider associations is an increasingly common strategy for both smaller and larger organizations to achieve the scale needed to successfully enter into value-based payment arrangements.[8] For additional information check out this report from Center for Health Care Strategies, which provides an overview of options and pilots to consider.
Building on existing opportunities for entering into value-based payment arrangements with managed care plans, there are emerging opportunities for California community health centers to shift to capitated payment and quality-based incentive programs through the Department of Health Care Services. These opportunities include the federally qualified health center Alternative Payment Methodology (APM) going live in June 2024, and the Equity Practice Transformation (EPT) program. In addition, providers may also be able to participate in a variety of new care models and payment reform efforts associated with California Advancing and Innovating Medi-Cal (CalAIM), the five-year plan launched in 2022 to transform California’s Medicaid program. Changes coming to care delivery and payment range from Enhanced Care Management (ECM) and Community Supports (also known as In Lieu of Services) for people with complex medical and social needs to streamlining and integrating behavioral health benefits for people with mental health and substance use disorder challenges. To read about the bold and wide-ranging Medi-Cal plans to improve payment and care delivery, visit the Department of Health Care Services website.
As community health centers consider adopting capitated payment that is linked to quality, engagement of the assigned-but-not-yet seen population is a critical step for successful performance on quality metrics that include these patients in the denominator population. This is a big shift in measurement and mindset for many organizations, and will require strong partnership with managed care plan partners to assure clarity about their patient assignment process.[9] Accounting for the assigned-but-not-yet-seen population may have important implications for your organization’s approach to empanelment as well, and should be considered when developing strategies to manage supply and demand. Working to engage this population provides an excellent opportunity to deploy community health workers in their capacity as outreach and enrollment agents, and to partner with community-based organizations to reach the people who are not coming in for visits.[10]
Improving quality in the context of capitation also requires providers to think expansively about how care is delivered, including adopting new care formats, new team roles, and new ways to plan, manage and coordinate care for the patient population.[11][12] Although capitation creates an opportunity to improve care, care transformation must be intentionally designed and implemented to realize the full potential of payment reform.[13] For more information about care model redesign, read and explore the PHMI Care Teams and Workforce Guide.
Endnotes
- Basu S, Phillips RS, Song Z, Bitton A, Landon BE. High Levels Of Capitation Payments Needed To Shift Primary Care Toward Proactive Team And Nonvisit Care. Health Aff (Millwood). 2017;36(9):1599-605.
- L’Esperance V, Gravelle H, Schofield P, Santos R, Ashworth M. Relationship between general practice capitation funding and the quality of primary care in England: a cross-sectional, 3-year study. BMJ Open. 2019;9(11):e030624.
- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Health care payment learning and action network. Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services; 2016 [September 11, 2023]. Available from: http://hcp-lan.org/workproducts/apm-refresh-whitepaper-final.pdf.
- Crook HL, Saunders RS, Roiland R, Higgins A, McClellan MB. A decade of value-based payment: lessons learned and implications for the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation, part 2. Health Affairs Blog. June 10, 2021.
- Crook HL, Saunders RS, Roiland R, Higgins A, McClellan MB. A decade of value-based payment: lessons learned and implications for the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation, part 2. Health Affairs Blog. June 10, 2021.
- Tobey R, Maxwell J, Turer E, Singer E, Lindenfeld Z, Nocon RS, et al. Health Centers and Value-Based Payment: A Framework for Health Center Payment Reform and Early Experiences in Medicaid Value-Based Payment in Seven States. Milbank Q. 2022;100(3):879-917.
- Tobey R, Maxwell J, Turer E, Singer E, Lindenfeld Z, Nocon RS, et al. Health Centers and Value-Based Payment: A Framework for Health Center Payment Reform and Early Experiences in Medicaid Value-Based Payment in Seven States. Milbank Q. 2022;100(3):879-917.
- Davlyatov G, Lord J, Puro N, Nancy Borkowski D. Does It Pay? An Examination of Interorganizational Relationships in Federally Qualified Health Centers. J Health Care Finance. 2020.
- Howe G, Silverman, K, Houston, R. California Federally Qualified Health Center Alternative Payment Model Implementation Guide. Oakland: California Health Care Foundation; [September 11, 2023]. Available from: https://www.chcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/CAFQHCAPMImplementationGuide.pdf.
- Gunderson JM, Wieland ML, Quirindongo-Cedeno O, Asiedu GB, Ridgeway JL, O’Brien MW, et al. Community Health Workers as an Extension of Care Coordination in Primary Care: A Community-Based Cosupervisory Model. J Ambul Care Manage. 2018;41(4):333-40.
- Howe G, Silverman, K, Houston, R. California Federally Qualified Health Center Alternative Payment Model Implementation Guide Oakland: California Health Care Foundation; [September 11, 2023]. Available from: https://www.chcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/CAFQHCAPMImplementationGuide.pdf
- Cottrell EK, Hall JD, Kautz G, Angier H, Likumahuwa-Ackman S, Sisulak L, et al. Reporting From the Front Lines: Implementing Oregon’s Alternative Payment Methodology in Federally Qualified Health Centers. J Ambul Care Manage. 2017;40(4):339-46.
- Hostetter M, Klein S. The perils and payoffs of alternative payment models for community health centers. New York: Commonwealth Fund; [September 11, 2023]. Available from: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/2022/jan/perils-and-payoffs-alternate-payment-models-community-health-centers.